The most common reason a seller wants a new estate agent is that the original agent over-promised and under-delivered.
Usually it shows in one way: no sale has been agreed within the sole agency period the seller signed up for. That frustration is understandable. But the agreement with the first agent does not disappear because you have stopped liking it, and the way you switch can cost you more than the switch saves.
The agreement you signed is a contract
The agreement with your estate agent is legally binding. Some sellers do not realise that until they want to leave. Two parts of it catch people out most:
- The period you signed for. Most sole agency agreements give the agent the home for a set number of weeks. Many sellers do not remember how long they agreed to, or when it started.
- The notice period. Many agreements continue after that period until you give written notice, and the notice itself can run for a further period. Until it has ended, the first agent may still be entitled to its fee in the circumstances the agreement sets out.
Agents have to explain key terms in writing under the Estate Agents (Provision of Information) Regulations 1991. Two are worth understanding before you do anything:
- Sole agency: one agent sells the home for the agreed period. You usually owe it the fee if you exchange contracts with a buyer it introduced, or if you sell through another agent during that period.
- Sole selling rights: stricter. The agent is owed its fee even if you find a buyer yourself, privately, during the agreement.
Our guide to choosing an estate agent covers these terms and the rest of the contract in more detail. If you are thinking of switching, the first job is to find your agreement and read what you actually signed.
The risk of paying two fees
This is the expensive mistake, and it is a very real risk.
Say a couple viewed your home through your first agent and did not offer. Months later, the home is with a new agent at a lower price, and the same couple buy it. Depending on the wording of your first agreement, the first agent may be entitled to its fee because it introduced the buyer, while the new agent expects its fee for the sale.
On a £600,000 sale at 1.5% plus VAT, each fee is £10,800. Paying it twice costs £21,600.
Agents do not always let it go. Some third-party firms have built their business on finding these missing fees and recovering them for agents.
Thinking of switching agents?
When your agreement ends, what you might still owe and who you would be paying for are worth knowing before you give notice. Tell Jon about your situation and get an independent view first.
Tell Jon about your situationWill a new agent fix it?
It depends on the agent. If the new agent is experienced and competent, they will establish what the issues were and should be able to solve them. That is the test to apply before you sign anything new.
The issues are often the ones in our guide to why a house is not selling: price, presentation, photography and strategy. A price set too high, or weak marketing, will follow the home to any agent that repeats it. A new agent who simply relists the same home at the same price, with the same photographs, is offering a new name, not a new result.
A good new agent should be able to tell you plainly why the home has not sold so far and what they would change. If they cannot, it is fair to ask whether switching will change anything.
Timing the switch
When to switch is part of the decision. Changing agents mid-agreement, or before the notice has run out, can leave you tied to two contracts at once. Waiting for the agreement to end costs time on the market, and every week on the portals can make a home look stale to buyers. How to weigh one against the other depends on your agreement, your buyers so far and how soon you need to move.
Not sure whether to wait or switch now?
The right timing depends on your agreement, your timescale and what has gone wrong so far. Jon can give you an independent view before you commit to a new agent.
Tell Jon about your situation